Another “help me choose a car” thread

[Slops]

Yeah, I'm so torn between these cars that I don't really know what I want.

Been looking at the following..

1. E63 S
2. M5
3. Model S performance or Plaid
4. Model X
5. RSQ8
6. X5M

It's mainly because I'm stuck with either a 4 door sedan vs SUV and getting away from those maintenance items like oil changes / gas... I'm just torn and would like to know what you guys would do. Maybe other choices?

[dgoldenz]

Have you driven them all?

[chenry]

Originally Posted by Slops

Yeah, I'm so torn between these cars that I don't really know what I want.

Been looking at the following..

1. E63 S
2. M5
3. Model S performance or Plaid
4. Model X
5. RSQ8
6. X5M

It's mainly because I'm stuck with either a 4 door sedan vs SUV and getting away from those maintenance items like oil changes / gas... I'm just torn and would like to know what you guys would do. Maybe other choices?

E63 S only because I've always wanted one

[cfm56d7b]

Originally Posted by dgoldenz

Have you driven them all?

That's perhaps the most sound advice. The only opinion that matters is yours.

My preference would be X5M with Donington Grey / Sakhir Orange because Audi RSQ8 doesn't offer these colors.

[stein_325i]

E63S would be my choice easily.

It solves the issue of being torn between a sedan and SUV as you can get the wagon which has all the benefits of a sedan and SUV and none of the SUV cons. Not to mention it has the best engine and exhaust of your choices, the handling is excellent, the refresh has a more comfortable suspension, the interior is lovely, and it will hold its value stronger due to it being a lower production wagon (aka unicorn).

M5 would be my second choice but I don't find it as exciting as the E63S. Tesla's aren't really fun outside of straight line performance so, I'd skip those. I'd also skip the high-performance SUV's and just get a regular luxury SUV and use the spare cash on a sports car.

[Burrcold]

My order (from what you listed) would be...

1. E63 S
2. M5
3. X5M
4. RSQ8
5. Model S performance or Plaid
6. Model X

[SteveinArizona]

I would want to know more about your needs and desires.

[Bingham]

E63 S all the way. Stunning body lines and an absolute beast/torque monster. The 63 amg variant engines are among the best power-plants on the road IMO...and best sounding if that’s important to you.

Test drove a couple x5ms for wife...utterly ridiculous and defies physics. I dare say it’s almost too much for an SUV.

Feel like I’m a few years away from an elect. car. Personally, I want to see more car options and more robust charging infrastructure.

Good luck with your decision- some great options! Maybe also consider and go drive an RS6/7?

[Alfisti]

M5 or E63 every day of the week, why are we even talking about this.

[Slops]

Originally Posted by dgoldenz

Have you driven them all?

No I have not driven them all yet, but I've been in all except the plaid (not built yet) and the RSQ8. I sat in a normal Qs8 at an auto show and loved the feel of the interior.

[Slops]

Originally Posted by dgoldenz

Have you driven them all?

The E63S caught my eye again when we went to order the wife's GLS 450, so I wondered what you guys thought before I ask for a formal test drive.

My needs aren't much... I've tracked my modded 335i a while ago, and I may look at something to do that in while still my DD. For that I think it narrows it down to the merc, bmw and Tesla plaid.

[stein_325i]

Originally Posted by Slops

The E63S caught my eye again when we went to order the wife's GLS 450, so I wondered what you guys thought before I ask for a formal test drive.

My needs aren't much... I've tracked my modded 335i a while ago, and I may look at something to do that in while still my DD. For that I think it narrows it down to the merc, bmw and Tesla plaid.

If you're okay with waiting, face-lifted E63S' should be hitting dealers shortly. They have updated looks, tech (MBUX) and a revised suspension for comfort. Test driving a pre-facelift should give you an idea for how the face-lifted model will drive albeit a bit harder in its ride due to the outgoing suspension tuning/design.

New M5's are also at dealers now and have a few updates in the tech and design. Those two would be the ones to compare in my opinion.

[overcoil]

I always felt that C, E, S class Mercedes didn't work well below 65 or 70 mph and thought it might be the front tow angle as the cause.
At 80 mph plus the Benz are incredible, rain, snow LOL .

If doing a lot of in town or 55 60 mph motorway cruising the M5 (low profile tires on brick/pave is also an issue) may be nicer and it's not just the steering.

If you test drive them curious if you find my experience accurate.

[Slops]

Originally Posted by stein_325i

If you're okay with waiting, face-lifted E63S' should be hitting dealers shortly. They have updated looks, tech (MBUX) and a revised suspension for comfort. Test driving a pre-facelift should give you an idea for how the face-lifted model will drive albeit a bit harder in its ride due to the outgoing suspension tuning/design.

New M5's are also at dealers now and have a few updates in the tech and design. Those two would be the ones to compare in my opinion.

Great advice thanks! I'm In a little hurry though as my C55 is already on it's last legs.

[R N M]

If you value interior quality then Tesla is not in same league as MB or BMW.

If you have $$$ and want something more special than get MB GT63 or Porsche Panamera GTS. You are looking at over $150k on those though.

M8 GC is another great option.

[c1pher]

Macan Turbo?

[Slops]

Originally Posted by R N M

If you value interior quality then Tesla is not in same league as MB or BMW.

If you have $$$ and want something more special than get MB GT63 or Porsche Panamera GTS. You are looking at over $150k on those though.

M8 GC is another great option.

Wow that GT63 is juicy! Thanks I'm looking into that one as well now.

[Germanauto]

Lol @ SUVs and EVs.

Take a look at the RS7 or a Panamera variant as well.

[stein_325i]

Originally Posted by Slops

Wow that GT63 is juicy! Thanks I'm looking into that one as well now.

My dealer had a used one for sale that they let me take a look around, car is awesome, the price tag is a bit hard to swallow though and discounts aren't really there, but its road presence is undeniable.

Panny ST is also a good idea to look at, one of the best looking wagons on sale, and a nice mix of luxury and sport, although I'd go for the V8's only. The used ones are where to look at in my opinion as the depreciation is severe, I remember for a while they still had brand new 2018 Turbo's early in 2020 with huge discounts.

[MBM340]

You have SUV's and also sedans here. There are so many variables here to determin...I would likely choose the M5 but it depends on how many kids and dogs you have.

[Slops]

Originally Posted by MBM340

You have SUV's and also sedans here. There are so many variables here to determin...I would likely choose the M5 but it depends on how many kids and dogs you have.

Yes I know I'm allll over the place! Only two young kids ages 8 and 11 and a small cocker spaniel... I love all the feedback, you guys are really helping me out here. Thank you

[Slops]

Originally Posted by stein_325i

My dealer had a used one for sale that they let me take a look around, car is awesome, the price tag is a bit hard to swallow though and discounts aren't really there, but its road presence is undeniable.

Panny ST is also a good idea to look at, one of the best looking wagons on sale, and a nice mix of luxury and sport, although I'd go for the V8's only. The used ones are where to look at in my opinion as the depreciation is severe, I remember for a while they still had brand new 2018 Turbo's early in 2020 with huge discounts.

Attachment 2488100
Attachment 2488101

Oh Boy! That red looks insane!!!