Opinions needed! You're looking in the $60-$65k range. Which of these.....

[adrian1480]

CTS-V and C63 are all going for $5k-$7k above sticker. Can't say I'm happy about this.

Hmmm.

[-=Hot|Ice=-]

Originally Posted by Boost Gomez

C63. The engine is bulletproof and you'll be driving around a beautiful looking, awesome sounding car.

[Magic-Man]

Originally Posted by adrian1480

CTS-V and C63 are all going for $5k-$7k above sticker. Can't say I'm happy about this.

Hmmm.

Not here. I was quoted invoice on a V Sedan or Coupe.

Shop around.

[adrian1480]

Originally Posted by Magic-Man

Not here. I was quoted invoice on a V Sedan or Coupe.

Shop around.

Cool. Will do.

[Vegas_Sirk]

I know this wasnt on the list but what about a lightly used GTR? Pick them up in the low 60s now the 2012s are out.

Its Japanese so it will be reliable. The maint is a little high, but its more then worth it for the performance.

[Bcube]

Late to the party but inserting my opinion nonetheless.

Test drove ISF, C63, and M3 back to back:
1) First time and last time I'll drive a Lexus. They're not for me.
2) C63: incredible engine. A bit slow on the transmission shifts. Suspension way too stiff for LA freeways. (if I had the means at the moment, I would pick up a used clk black series for a track car, the motor is that righteous) but not a DD for me.
3) M3: only thing holding it back as a perfect DD, is asymal fuel economy. I'd go for a 1M instead.

Later that week I test drove a CTS-V coupe with a stick. Had the OMG power like the C63 but the road manners of an M3. Fuel economy is a strike against for DD. The coupe had the exact options I would pick which meant a MSRP of ~$70K. Bit too expensive for daily grind commuting.

Used AM Vantage. Maintenance prices are the killer. It was a ~$110K car. Even though depreciation makes them relatively cheap on the used market, they still command exotic car maintenance prices. Parts and labor don't get less expensive just because the car gets older. One can buy a used 2005-6 low mileage Maserati GranSport all day long but can one afford the annual and bi-annual services that range from a few hundred dollars for an oil change to the $1800 for a full service. How about the $5K clutch job very 20K miles. These prices mimic those for the baby Aston.

[Precision]

Originally Posted by M3This

I know this wasnt on the list but what about a lightly used GTR? Pick them up in the low 60s now the 2012s are out.

Its Japanese so it will be reliable. The maint is a little high, but its more then worth it for the performance.

false, transmission fluid is $118 a quart too

http://www.m3post.com/forums/showthread.php?t=182934

[Vegas_Sirk]

Originally Posted by Precision

false, transmission fluid is $118 a quart too

http://www.m3post.com/forums/showthread.php?t=182934

Transmission problems where mostly in 09, the 10s and 11s do not have that issue nor the warranty issues.

The 20K mile service is the one big service cost for the car but besides that its not that big of a deal esp when you compare the performance to anything else.

[M3_WC]

Originally Posted by adrian1480

CTS-V and C63 are all going for $5k-$7k above sticker. Can't say I'm happy about this.

Hmmm.

Not easy to get a C63 coupe. The Benz dealer I went to only had two allocations, both taken. Cars won't be delivered until January.

[M3_WC]

I would forget about the 335xi, with the new 3-series coming to dealers next spring.

[Precision]

Originally Posted by M3This

Transmission problems where mostly in 09, the 10s and 11s do not have that issue nor the warranty issues.

The 20K mile service is the one big service cost for the car but besides that its not that big of a deal esp when you compare the performance to anything else.

No, transmission problems were only more pronounced in those years because of launch control and the warranty issue was related. The GTR is not to be confused for simply reliable, it is expensive to maintain and expensive to repair, the drive-train is not solid and only with age will you see how expensive a twin turbo 6 in it is to take care of.

The car is too new to pass judgement beyond what is already known, I do not for-see a reliable efficient car.

Fast+Reliable+Cheap = pick two

[uwotm8]

CTS-V in a heartbeat

[Vegas_Sirk]

Originally Posted by Precision

No, transmission problems were only more pronounced in those years because of launch control and the warranty issue was related. The GTR is not to be confused for simply reliable, it is expensive to maintain and expensive to repair, the drive-train is not solid and only with age will you see how expensive a twin turbo 6 in it is to take care of.

The car is too new to pass judgement beyond what is already known, I do not for-see a reliable efficient car.

Fast+Reliable+Cheap = pick two

Well I disagree, but it already show Ill never change your mind.

I looked into GTR significantly, prior to getting my 5 series, and know all the problems plus the full cost of maint over the maint intervals. The car it rock solid reliable as long as your not using launch control 24/7. Besides this car is NOT A DRAG car, its built for a road course.If you want a drag car I suggest something else. Its like the same people bitching about their trannys and clutches going on on their Evos when using launch control, when I use to have my Evo IX.

A few of my good friends are instructors at Exotic Car Racing here in Vegas and they said the GTR is hands down the most reliable and fastest cars out there (the 458 Italia is close) and nothing comes close for the money.

[graider]

3.) New C63 AMG Coupe hands down.

[blue2fire]

The Jaguar XK is a good car, the reliability and resale is the best you can find for a Jaguar but the simple fact that you are looking at a C63 and 911 tells me that you would still like a bit more sport than it is capable of.

It is a good cruiser but unless you go for an XKR, it lacks sportiness. If you are waiting for a bit, you could go for the XE that will be launched at your budget.

[Precision]

Originally Posted by Boost Gomez

C63. The engine is bulletproof and you'll be driving around a beautiful looking, awesome sounding car.

Oh yea? I call BS and so doesnt this class action lawsuit for AMG V8 Failures

http://www.autoblog.com/2011/09/22/c...lleges-amg-v8/

[-=Hot|Ice=-]

From the list C63 AMG Coupe

[Lowest_Frequency]

Did you consider GT500?

[335i101]

Did u consider a salvaged Enzo???

That was a joke.

I am shocked with all the GM support. I have owned many and now we all we own them thanks to the recent bail out...

Anyway, in my opinion, the the CTS-v's come across as to plasticy to me. (I must admit I have note been in or driven the new model CTS-V) maybe something I need to revisit.

Also IMHO when I buy new, reliability is not much of a factor, all the dealerships, in general, will treat you good in the case you need them. I look more at mech. concerns when buying used.

Maybe I am a little strange, but when I am under warranty and something acts up...I knowing that they are covering the bill.

I think you are in a tough price range so close to buing a used "supercar" also close to buying GM.....

Good luck, I would lease the new M5.

[Turbo>NA]

OP, you dont want to waste money on taking care of the car?

Then FORGET about the Aston and Porsche. 2nd, the best one that fits your needs that WILL also be fun to ride in is the BMW 35 or C63.

[graider]

actually OP, i rather have the 2012 c63 sedan. cheaper than the coupe and better looking IMO.

[Boost Gomez]

Originally Posted by Precision

Oh yea? I call BS and so doesnt this class action lawsuit for AMG V8 Failures

http://www.autoblog.com/2011/09/22/c...lleges-amg-v8/

I wasn't referring to highly modded engines.