New Ytest
Sign out
Bimmerpost
Login
BMW E39 5-Series Forum | 5Post.com
BMW Garage BMW Meets Register Today's Posts  
Go Back   BMW E39 5-Series Forum | 5Post.com > BIMMERPOST Universal Forums > General Automotive (non-BMW) Talk + Photos/Videos

View Poll Results: Should I get a manual car next?
Row row row my own, gently down the street 51 83.61%
Slushbox 5 8.20%
Wut? 5 8.20%
Voters: 61. You may not vote on this poll

Post Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
      12-19-2021, 01:34 PM   #45
Efthreeoh
General
United_States
18974
Rep
19,603
Posts

 
Drives: The E90 + Z4 Coupe & Z3 R'ster
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Virginia

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by jkoral View Post
I've driven a BMW manual since 1996 and plan to keep buying manual as long as I can. It's slower, but more engaging. I don't derive a paycheck from my lap times or the red light drag strip, so it makes no difference to me. I've daily driven all my manuals and never tired, or regretted it, even in stop and go traffic (Boston area) - although since covid-19, my M2 has sat in the garage since March 2020.

When BMW no longer offers a manual, I would consider switching brands. But with the G87 LCI ending production in Spring 2029, I should be able to keep driving BMW manuals to at least 2035 (I keep my cars a long time).

BTW, I taught my wife to drive manual and she enjoys it. She bought a manual for her next car (back in 1997). She has only driven my car on very rare occasions (once per year, if that).
So, I'd like to address this idea that modern automatics shift faster than modern manual transmissions. So, in cases where the automatic is a PDK or dual-clutch automatic, sure those transmissions, which are really manual gearboxes anyway, can shift faster than a traditional 3-pedal manual. And some of the torque converter automatics with 6, 8, and 10 speed automatics can be programmed to shift faster as well, but the speeds of those shifts are tied to the amount of throttle input the driver is providing relative to his acceleration desires. But in real world street use, a dual clutch or torque converter auto transmission shifts no faster in traffic than a 3-pedal at moderate throttle input. So, to me, in real application, how fast some modern automatic transmissions can shift is mostly irrelevant; they CAN shift a little faster than a 3-pedal, but in real use, mostly they really don't. I'd much rather trade a small amount of theoretical shift speed for far greater gear selection choice, especially the instant availability to have neutral at any time.

The above point is tied to my question to the OP if he thinks manumatics can shift faster than a 3-pedal. If you are a true manual transmission driver, shifting is mostly an unconscious act that just is a part of driving, as much as steering is used to change directions.
__________________
A manual transmission can be set to "comfort", "sport", and "track" modes simply by the technique and speed at which you shift it; it doesn't need "modes", modes are for manumatics that try to behave like a real 3-pedal manual transmission. If you can money-shift it, it's a manual transmission. "Yeah, but NO ONE puts an automatic trans shift knob on a manual transmission."

Last edited by Efthreeoh; 10-27-2024 at 12:20 PM..
Appreciate 2
      12-19-2021, 01:42 PM   #46
Efthreeoh
General
United_States
18974
Rep
19,603
Posts

 
Drives: The E90 + Z4 Coupe & Z3 R'ster
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Virginia

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by wtwo3 View Post
I appreciate the input. The point of me asking the question is not to get a definitive yes/no answer (yes, I know, I set up a poll and asked a yes/no question), but to gain perspective that I currently don't have. 100% understand those are other people's perspectives, but they're better than no perspective at all outside of the handful of times I've driven a manual car.

I think the fact that I'm asking the question to begin with means I'm willing to commit to a lifestyle change. If I wasn't then I'd have literally no reason to create this post.

But to answer your questions:
- Automatics being faster is a combination of the car and the driver doing the shifting. As a novice, I'd fully expect an equivalent auto to easily outperform me rowing my own gears. That being said, it's a VERY small con for me if at all. After a certain point incremental increases in speed just don't matter anymore, else I'd have ended up in a Tesla by now.

- I'm not really worried about heavy traffic since I don't experience that on a normal basis, but gaining perspective for people who have is valuable input for me.

- Being fully engaged with the act of driving sounds amazing. Do I want to be fully engaged 100% of the time? It's very hard for me to answer that... inclination is to say yes, but again this is where gaining people's perspective comes into play (i.e. do you sometimes get tired of it, or is it something which makes you look forward to it every time you sit in the car)

- Shifting a "manumatic" is nowhere near the same as a true manual.

I'm not 100% relying on an online forum to help answer this for me.. I'm being proactive (at least I think I am). I just set up a rental for an Evo X for a few days next week to see how I like driving it around my hood for some additional perspective. I'll report back how it makes me feel.
I never tire of having full manual control of gear selection.
__________________
A manual transmission can be set to "comfort", "sport", and "track" modes simply by the technique and speed at which you shift it; it doesn't need "modes", modes are for manumatics that try to behave like a real 3-pedal manual transmission. If you can money-shift it, it's a manual transmission. "Yeah, but NO ONE puts an automatic trans shift knob on a manual transmission."
Appreciate 3
wtwo318947.00
nicholasn261.00
      12-19-2021, 01:48 PM   #47
Red Bread
Major General
United_States
4457
Rep
9,160
Posts

 
Drives: Smog machines
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Austin, TX

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Efthreeoh View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by wtwo3 View Post
I appreciate the input. The point of me asking the question is not to get a definitive yes/no answer (yes, I know, I set up a poll and asked a yes/no question), but to gain perspective that I currently don't have. 100% understand those are other people's perspectives, but they're better than no perspective at all outside of the handful of times I've driven a manual car.

I think the fact that I'm asking the question to begin with means I'm willing to commit to a lifestyle change. If I wasn't then I'd have literally no reason to create this post.

But to answer your questions:
- Automatics being faster is a combination of the car and the driver doing the shifting. As a novice, I'd fully expect an equivalent auto to easily outperform me rowing my own gears. That being said, it's a VERY small con for me if at all. After a certain point incremental increases in speed just don't matter anymore, else I'd have ended up in a Tesla by now.

- I'm not really worried about heavy traffic since I don't experience that on a normal basis, but gaining perspective for people who have is valuable input for me.

- Being fully engaged with the act of driving sounds amazing. Do I want to be fully engaged 100% of the time? It's very hard for me to answer that... inclination is to say yes, but again this is where gaining people's perspective comes into play (i.e. do you sometimes get tired of it, or is it something which makes you look forward to it every time you sit in the car)

- Shifting a "manumatic" is nowhere near the same as a true manual.

I'm not 100% relying on an online forum to help answer this for me.. I'm being proactive (at least I think I am). I just set up a rental for an Evo X for a few days next week to see how I like driving it around my hood for some additional perspective. I'll report back how it makes me feel.
I never tire of having full manual control of gear selection.
Agreed. I find it more tiring to drive an automatic in traffic. Holding down the brake takes more effort, and the car always trying to move forward in stop and go traffic gets annoying. The spousal Volvo has a button to stop the creep, it's pretty nice.

I've lived in Dallas, Orange County and Austin, all have bad traffic and I've never once regretted having nothing but manuals.
Appreciate 2
Efthreeoh18973.50
      12-19-2021, 02:02 PM   #48
Efthreeoh
General
United_States
18974
Rep
19,603
Posts

 
Drives: The E90 + Z4 Coupe & Z3 R'ster
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Virginia

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Red Bread View Post
Agreed. I find it more tiring to drive an automatic in traffic. Holding down the brake takes more effort, and the car always trying to move forward in stop and go traffic gets annoying. The spousal Volvo has a button to stop the creep, it's pretty nice.

I've lived in Dallas, Orange County and Austin, all have bad traffic and I've never once regretted having nothing but manuals.
That's the beauty of having instant access to neutral; and two ways to get it, via your left foot, or right hand. Instant torque release of the drivetrain.
__________________
A manual transmission can be set to "comfort", "sport", and "track" modes simply by the technique and speed at which you shift it; it doesn't need "modes", modes are for manumatics that try to behave like a real 3-pedal manual transmission. If you can money-shift it, it's a manual transmission. "Yeah, but NO ONE puts an automatic trans shift knob on a manual transmission."
Appreciate 0
      12-19-2021, 02:46 PM   #49
BMWCCA1
BMW Owner Since 1971
2483
Rep
1,509
Posts

 
Drives: 1964 700 Sport Cabriolet
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Central Virginia

iTrader: (2)

Garage List
2013 BMW 128i  [10.00]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Red Bread View Post
Agreed. I find it more tiring to drive an automatic in traffic. Holding down the brake takes more effort, and the car always trying to move forward in stop and go traffic gets annoying. The spousal Volvo has a button to stop the creep, it's pretty nice.
Every new BMW today has Brake Hold if it has an automatic. It's been around for quite some time.
Appreciate 0
      12-19-2021, 03:37 PM   #50
wtwo3
Major General
wtwo3's Avatar
18947
Rep
5,632
Posts

 
Drives: 23 X7 40i; 23 M3; 24 cooper s
Join Date: Aug 2019
Location: IL

iTrader: (0)

Garage List
Quote:
Originally Posted by BMWCCA1 View Post
Every new BMW today has Brake Hold if it has an automatic. It's been around for quite some time.
Mine has traffic jam assist. Car does everything for you, braking, accelerating, stopping, starting, steering, etc.

Although I was planning to not equip my next car with it anyway since I don't get much use out of it as I don't get much traffic at all.
__________________
2023 BMW X7 xDrive40i
2023 BMW M3 6MT
2024 Mini Cooper S Convertible

'20 BMW m340i... '20 BMW X5 40i... '16 Infiniti Q50 RS 400... '10 Lexus RX 350... '08 Lexus IS 350... '00 Nissan Maxima... '93 Nissan Maxima
Appreciate 0
      12-19-2021, 05:09 PM   #51
Saenenj
New Member
6
Rep
6
Posts

 
Drives: BMW X2, Mercedes CLA 45
Join Date: Dec 2021
Location: Belgium

iTrader: (0)

Yes go for manual, unless youre constant in traffic jams.
Appreciate 1
wtwo318947.00
      12-19-2021, 05:44 PM   #52
Red Bread
Major General
United_States
4457
Rep
9,160
Posts

 
Drives: Smog machines
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Austin, TX

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by BMWCCA1 View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by Red Bread View Post
Agreed. I find it more tiring to drive an automatic in traffic. Holding down the brake takes more effort, and the car always trying to move forward in stop and go traffic gets annoying. The spousal Volvo has a button to stop the creep, it's pretty nice.
Every new BMW today has Brake Hold if it has an automatic. It's been around for quite some time.
Our F30 might have had it. That thing required so many button pushes just to in-Buick it's dumb ass I stopped buying BMWs.
Appreciate 1
Efthreeoh18973.50
      12-19-2021, 08:29 PM   #53
RM7
Brigadier General
RM7's Avatar
3021
Rep
3,627
Posts

 
Drives: Camaro SS 1LE
Join Date: May 2015
Location: Alaska

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Red Bread View Post
Agreed. I find it more tiring to drive an automatic in traffic. Holding down the brake takes more effort, and the car always trying to move forward in stop and go traffic gets annoying. The spousal Volvo has a button to stop the creep, it's pretty nice.

I've lived in Dallas, Orange County and Austin, all have bad traffic and I've never once regretted having nothing but manuals.
Adaptative Cruise Control.

Once you get it, you can't live without it in places like this IME. Pushing a heavy clutch disc gets tiring and annoying after a little while. Standing on the brake of an auto gets annoying in the same way. But being able to let the car just go and get there when you get there is priceless.
__________________
Current: 2018 Camaro SS 1LE, 2023 Colorado ZR2. Former: BMW 428i Gran Coupe.
Appreciate 2
Red Bread4456.50
NervoS122.00
      12-19-2021, 08:31 PM   #54
Red Bread
Major General
United_States
4457
Rep
9,160
Posts

 
Drives: Smog machines
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Austin, TX

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by RM7 View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by Red Bread View Post
Agreed. I find it more tiring to drive an automatic in traffic. Holding down the brake takes more effort, and the car always trying to move forward in stop and go traffic gets annoying. The spousal Volvo has a button to stop the creep, it's pretty nice.

I've lived in Dallas, Orange County and Austin, all have bad traffic and I've never once regretted having nothing but manuals.
Adaptative Cruise Control.

Once you get it, you can't live without it in places like this IME. Pushing a heavy clutch disc gets tiring and annoying after a little while. Standing on the brake of an auto gets annoying in the same way. But being able to let the car just go and get there when you get there is priceless.
Agree. We have it on our Volvo and it's the best automatic I've driven. I'd assume any brand is similar, not suggesting Volvo is the real reason.

It's great, for an automatic. I never use cruise on my car and have some of the nannies disabled. But that's a manual.
Appreciate 0
      12-20-2021, 01:47 AM   #55
nick3753
Lieutenant Colonel
nick3753's Avatar
1134
Rep
1,518
Posts

 
Drives: 2012 e92 M3 DCT ZCP
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Michigan

iTrader: (0)

Garage List
2017 Audi S6  [0.00]
1997 BMW 328i Touring  [0.00]
2012 BMW M3  [0.00]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tambohamilton View Post
Go auto. If you have to ask, there is only one answer.
Bingo!
Appreciate 1
Efthreeoh18973.50
      12-20-2021, 08:31 AM   #56
KevinGS
Colonel
4178
Rep
2,355
Posts

 
Drives: Past 2015 M4, Current 2013 M3
Join Date: Jun 2015
Location: Maryland

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tambohamilton View Post
Go auto. If you have to ask, there is only one answer.
I agree with Tambo. You KNOW when you want a manual, and then you simply get one, "no questions asked". If there's any doubt, just get an auto.

I've owned 4 manuals, and I don't regret any of them...but now that I've had 4 consecutive autos or DCTs, I don't miss the manual enough to get another one, unless it's a "fun" car...like a GT3 or something. I miss it occasionally, like twice a year. All other times, I'm totally happy with my auto.
Appreciate 2
wtwo318947.00
Efthreeoh18973.50
      12-20-2021, 08:35 AM   #57
wtwo3
Major General
wtwo3's Avatar
18947
Rep
5,632
Posts

 
Drives: 23 X7 40i; 23 M3; 24 cooper s
Join Date: Aug 2019
Location: IL

iTrader: (0)

Garage List
Quote:
Originally Posted by KevinGS View Post
I've owned 4 manuals, and I don't regret any of them...but now that I've had 4 consecutive autos or DCTs, I don't miss the manual enough to get another one, unless it's a "fun" car...like a GT3 or something. I miss it occasionally, like twice a year. All other times, I'm totally happy with my auto.
Thanks for this perspective. I've owned nothing but autos my entire life and am thinking about making this change, but admittedly don't totally know what I'm getting into outside of those few times I've driven manual. I'm hoping over the next several months to begin driving more manual cars (through rentals) to see what it's like to drive on a daily basis around my hood. Hoping that gives me a bit more clarity on "I have to have manual" or, "It's cool but I'm fine with auto".

One thing I'll mention again though, me asking the question isn't indication of me having doubts. It's just a call for perspectives (like yours) in case I'm missing something since I don't have the experience. I have this itch to own a manual and gain more engagement from the car - this is more a sanity check. I probably should have worded my thread better... like, "I'm strongly considering getting my first manual car, anything I need to consider?"
__________________
2023 BMW X7 xDrive40i
2023 BMW M3 6MT
2024 Mini Cooper S Convertible

'20 BMW m340i... '20 BMW X5 40i... '16 Infiniti Q50 RS 400... '10 Lexus RX 350... '08 Lexus IS 350... '00 Nissan Maxima... '93 Nissan Maxima

Last edited by wtwo3; 12-20-2021 at 08:45 AM..
Appreciate 0
      12-20-2021, 08:38 AM   #58
unluky
Major
unluky's Avatar
7675
Rep
1,261
Posts

 
Drives: 04 z4 3.0 Sport & 15 X5 35i XD
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Sedalia, MO

iTrader: (0)

Garage List
Quote:
Originally Posted by Murf993 View Post
Is this a trick question?

So unless you are a serious fanatic about shift times etc and most of the people you meet or will talk it up can't get around the track as fast as they will tell you. If you want to feel like you're actually engage with a sports car go for the stick....seriously, this is a trick question right?
Is this a trick question?


Is this EVEN a question is what I thought!!! I have had a manual in my garage for over 25 years straight now.
__________________
2015 X5 XDrive 35i - 2004 Z4 3.0 Sport
Appreciate 1
Murf99314095.00
      12-20-2021, 08:46 AM   #59
wtwo3
Major General
wtwo3's Avatar
18947
Rep
5,632
Posts

 
Drives: 23 X7 40i; 23 M3; 24 cooper s
Join Date: Aug 2019
Location: IL

iTrader: (0)

Garage List
Quote:
Originally Posted by unluky View Post
Is this a trick question?


Is this EVEN a question is what I thought!!! I have had a manual in my garage for over 25 years straight now.
I've had nothing but autos.... hence the question
__________________
2023 BMW X7 xDrive40i
2023 BMW M3 6MT
2024 Mini Cooper S Convertible

'20 BMW m340i... '20 BMW X5 40i... '16 Infiniti Q50 RS 400... '10 Lexus RX 350... '08 Lexus IS 350... '00 Nissan Maxima... '93 Nissan Maxima
Appreciate 0
      12-20-2021, 08:50 AM   #60
Murf993
Major
Murf993's Avatar
14095
Rep
1,336
Posts

 
Drives: Porsche 993
Join Date: Mar 2020
Location: Dog Lake, South Frontenac, Ontario Canada

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by unluky View Post
Is this a trick question?


Is this EVEN a question is what I thought!!! I have had a manual in my garage for over 25 years straight now.
I have had a stick since the second car I owned in 1980.
Appreciate 0
      12-20-2021, 09:16 AM   #61
INTMD8
Private First Class
152
Rep
116
Posts

 
Drives: 2012 E91 manual
Join Date: Aug 2016
Location: Lake Villa IL

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by RM7 View Post
Adaptative Cruise Control.

Once you get it, you can't live without it in places like this IME. Pushing a heavy clutch disc gets tiring and annoying after a little while. Standing on the brake of an auto gets annoying in the same way. But being able to let the car just go and get there when you get there is priceless.
Adaptive is not usable for my drives.

Commute is high speed with a lot of congestion, people pull into the spot the adaptive cruise leaves in front of you.


Anyway, I always prefer manual trans. If I have a car without one, it wasn't offered.
__________________
12 E91. 96 C4S. 95 F355. 87 Toyota 4x4. 69 Charger. 59 Cadillac.
Appreciate 1
Efthreeoh18973.50
      12-20-2021, 09:26 AM   #62
VAcurler
Private First Class
119
Rep
150
Posts

 
Drives: 21 F23 M240i MT + 09 e90 328i
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: Colorado

iTrader: (0)

Having never owned an automatic (including an SUV in the late 90s) my answer is that any new car purchased in 2022 should either be a proper 3 pedal car or a purely electric vehicle.
Appreciate 4
wtwo318947.00
Efthreeoh18973.50
nicholasn261.00
      12-20-2021, 10:59 AM   #63
Darth One
drunk poster
Darth One's Avatar
United_States
6608
Rep
3,649
Posts

 
Drives: M4 GTS | E46 M3
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: FL

iTrader: (0)

You already mentioned the most important point - if anyone ever wanted to try owning a manual, now's the time, and it's running out.

You can buy a manual now, figure out if you like it, and if not you've had a life experience.

If you wait much longer, you'll never know what you missed (unless you buy an older car - which isn't a bad option considering what's out there these days)
Appreciate 1
wtwo318947.00
      12-20-2021, 11:27 AM   #64
Esteban
Major General
Esteban's Avatar
United_States
53169
Rep
7,237
Posts

 
Drives: a slow car fast
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: SoCal

iTrader: (0)

As others have said, get a manual. Unless you don't really enjoy driving, and a car is just an appliance to you, taking you from point A to point B and back again.

Also, with one child and another on the way I say get 4 doors. When my kids were little I had a Supra and it became a real PITA getting out and pulling the front seats forward every time they had to get in and get out. It's so much easier to just open the back doors. Unless your kids won't be riding in your car very much.
Appreciate 1
wtwo318947.00
      12-20-2021, 11:57 AM   #65
HighlandPete
Lieutenant General
6548
Rep
15,857
Posts

 
Drives: BMW F11 535i Touring
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Scotland, Highland Region

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Esteban View Post
As others have said, get a manual. Unless you don't really enjoy driving, and a car is just an appliance to you, taking you from point A to point B and back again.
Driving/choosing AT or MT isn't a binary decision. BTW, what's the choice really got to do with whether you enjoy driving?

Being in the UK we were brought up with MT, most of us never looked at AT until AT became more sophisticated, and had some really tangible driver adaptation built into the transmission management.

I now drive AT, enjoy driving AT just as much as driving MT. I get a bit of seat time in MT rental and courtesy cars, but would not buy one as a daily driver.

BTW, I go back to driving MT with crash boxes, (no synchromesh) and 3-speed AT. The first AT which grabbed my attention was the ZF 5-speed, made so much sense coupled to a BMW V8.

The 8-speed burrs the lines between choosing AT vs. MT, IMO. We take our pick on how we want to drive, and how much we want to be involved.

Learn to drive an AT properly, explore its finer nuances, and it can be as involving to drive as a stick.

BTW: 35-years owning/driving MT, 19-years owning/driving AT.
Appreciate 1
wtwo318947.00
      12-20-2021, 12:34 PM   #66
Esteban
Major General
Esteban's Avatar
United_States
53169
Rep
7,237
Posts

 
Drives: a slow car fast
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: SoCal

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by HighlandPete View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by Esteban View Post
As others have said, get a manual. Unless you don't really enjoy driving, and a car is just an appliance to you, taking you from point A to point B and back again.
Driving/choosing AT or MT isn't a binary decision. BTW, what's the choice really got to do with whether you enjoy driving?

Being in the UK we were brought up with MT, most of us never looked at AT until AT became more sophisticated, and had some really tangible driver adaptation built into the transmission management.

I now drive AT, enjoy driving AT just as much as driving MT. I get a bit of seat time in MT rental and courtesy cars, but would not buy one as a daily driver.

BTW, I go back to driving MT with crash boxes, (no synchromesh) and 3-speed AT. The first AT which grabbed my attention was the ZF 5-speed, made so much sense coupled to a BMW V8.

The 8-speed burrs the lines between choosing AT vs. MT, IMO. We take our pick on how we want to drive, and how much we want to be involved.

Learn to drive an AT properly, explore its finer nuances, and it can be as involving to drive as a stick.

BTW: 35-years owning/driving MT, 19-years owning/driving AT.
Glad you're enjoying your AT. Read this thread and you'll see most agree with me, but you do you. BTW, I've been driving for 50+ years now and I think I know the difference between a manual and an auto.
Appreciate 2
Efthreeoh18973.50
Post Reply

Bookmarks


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:28 AM.




5post
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
1Addicts.com, BIMMERPOST.com, E90Post.com, F30Post.com, M3Post.com, ZPost.com, 5Post.com, 6Post.com, 7Post.com, XBimmers.com logo and trademark are properties of BIMMERPOST