Firearms

[LBBF87]

Originally Posted by Sedan_Clan

Assault rifles is a misnomer used by the anti-gun crowd. AR-15's aren't assault rifles. Arguably, it is easier to be accurate and efficient with an AR-15 than it is a semi-automatic handgun.

It's a really good question, but also a tough one. You previous comment about medical records makes sense, but how else are we supposed to keep up with someone's mental health?

I liked the way NJ went about it. Two references, about a 60 day waiting period, and all of the applications for FIDs (what you need to buy any gun) is reviewed by your local police department.

Not much digs into your mental health, but a standardized psych evaluation by your doctor might suffice?

That still does leave a blind spot for people who deteriorate mentally though it does seem that these people who carry out these attacks go on a buying spree right before the attacks…so the above could work.

The reality is as someone else pointed out before, someone is going to like the changes, and someone else will not. However it seems the majority are ready for serious changes.

In regards to age however, most of these mass shooters seem to be between 18-21, agreed it's not exclusive, but it can't hurt to wait for peoples brains to be completely developed can it?

[Sara]

Originally Posted by Sedan_Clan

How much more difficult does it need to be? In California - one of the most anti-2A states in the union - you have to pass a written test and complete a background check with the DOJ. That is reasonable. The second amendment isn't a right given with contingencies (…mandatory training, accuracy, etc.). The onus is on the owner, just like everything else that requires proficiency to be good at. We already have background checks for private sales here and we already have waiting periods (…Why the arbitrary 30 day suggestion? What makes 30 days any better than 10 days?). Mental health is an issue, but now you're sliding down a slippery slope when you start mandating medical records. You start giving the government that level of control and it won't be long before it's infringing on areas of your life that it wasn't intended to.

I can’t speak for California, but in Louisiana it’s way too easy. All my purchases were less than a 10 minute transaction.

My first firearm I purchased long ago. Just decided I was bored and wanted a gun. I was able to walk in, with no prior firearm experience, give them my ID, fill out a two page sheet, and I walked out with a Glock 26. Just scary to me. I’ve since worked with an instructor, taken many firearm classes, now have my conceal carry permit. To me, it should have been the other way around. I didn’t even know how to release the magazine or how to load it for Pete’s sake.

As for 30 days as opposed to 10, it was just a number I threw out. However long it takes the dealer or whoever is selling to fully vet you would be sufficient.

I don’t have all the answers, I just know in Louisiana it’s too easy to obtain a firearm. I would never sell a horse to someone who didn’t know how to handle a horse. That’s an accident waiting to happen. Why are guns any different?

Not trying to start a war here. Just thinking out loud

[LBBF87]

Originally Posted by Sara

I can't speak for California, but in Louisiana it's way too easy. All my purchases were less than a 10 minute transaction.

My first firearm I purchased long ago. Just decided I was bored and wanted a gun. I was able to walk in, with no prior firearm experience, give them my ID, fill out a two page sheet, and I walked out with a Glock 26. Just scary to me. I've since worked with an instructor, taken many firearm classes, now have my conceal carry permit. To me, it should have been the other way around. I didn't even know how to release the magazine or how to load it for Pete's sake.

As for 30 days as opposed to 10, it was just a number I threw out. However long it takes the dealer or whoever is selling to fully vet you would be sufficient.

I don't have all the answers, I just know in Louisiana it's too easy to obtain a firearm. I would never sell a horse to someone who didn't know how to handle a horse. That's an accident waiting to happen. Why are guns any different?

Not trying to start a war here. Just thinking out loud

I think your 30 days has some merit though, maybe even longer. It may mean some of these people are caught, or get help before they can do harm.

Then again maybe not, the guy in Buffalo seems to have been planning for a very long time.

[Killed by Death]

Who's more ammo rich? Probably everyone but I'm feeling secure on 9mm anyway

Still can't find much 38 or 357

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by LBBF87

It's a really good question, but also a tough one. You previous comment about medical records makes sense, but how else are we supposed to keep up with someone's mental health?

I liked the way NJ went about it. Two references, about a 60 day waiting period, and all of the applications for FIDs (what you need to buy any gun) is reviewed by your local police department.

Not much digs into your mental health, but a standardized psych evaluation by your doctor might suffice?

That still does leave a blind spot for people who deteriorate mentally though it does seem that these people who carry out these attacks go on a buying spree right before the attacks…so the above could work.

The reality is as someone else pointed out before, someone is going to like the changes, and someone else will not. However it seems the majority are ready for serious changes.

In regards to age however, most of these mass shooters seem to be between 18-21, agreed it's not exclusive, but it can't hurt to wait for peoples brains to be completely developed can it?

Well the reality is that there's no real way to do it without infringing on their HIPAA rights, and in doing that it makes everything else open game. Like I said, slippery slope.

The idea about a psych evaluation sounds good on the surface, but ask anybody who has every gone through a psych evaluation (…cough…every police officer….cough), their conclusions are rarely ever in line. It's a subjective conclusion rather than an objective one. It will not fix the issue.

These mass shootings that occur aren't cookie cutter. Some have clinically documented mental issues while others claim to have issues because it's convenient and/or is designed as a sympathetic petition to those who may be tasked with judgment (…e.g…jurors, the judge, etc.). Some use illegally obtained firearms and some use legally owned and/or possessed firearms. Some have temporary mental breakdowns because of a trauma and others are just evil people. There's no real rhyme or reason.

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by Sara

I can't speak for California, but in Louisiana it's way too easy. All my purchases were less than a 10 minute transaction.

My first firearm I purchased long ago. Just decided I was bored and wanted a gun. I was able to walk in, with no prior firearm experience, give them my ID, fill out a two page sheet, and I walked out with a Glock 26. Just scary to me. I've since worked with an instructor, taken many firearm classes, now have my conceal carry permit. To me, it should have been the other way around. I didn't even know how to release the magazine or how to load it for Pete's sake.

As for 30 days as opposed to 10, it was just a number I threw out. However long it takes the dealer or whoever is selling to fully vet you would be sufficient.

I don't have all the answers, I just know in Louisiana it's too easy to obtain a firearm. I would never sell a horse to someone who didn't know how to handle a horse. That's an accident waiting to happen. Why are guns any different?

Not trying to start a war here. Just thinking out loud

Now imagine needing to grant access to all of your medical records in order to obtain that permit. Furthermore, have you seen a psychologist? Should you have been required to see a psychologist before obtaining a permit to defend yourself? What if you were required to see a psychologist on a regular basis and make those records available?!? After all, you're now in the position where you're carrying a firearm and you just might have to shoot someone. Have you ever considered the psychological, legal and financial ramifications of pulling that trigger in the name of "self-defense"? Are you prepared to potentially lose your livelihood, your daughter and your freedom because of that decision? If we start probing, the questions become endless.

[Sara]

Originally Posted by Sedan_Clan

Now imagine needing to grant access to all of your medical records in order to obtain that permit. Furthermore, have you seen a psychologist? Should you have been required to see a psychologist before obtaining a permit to defend yourself? What if you were required to see a psychologist on a regular basis and make those records available?!? After all, you're now in the position where you're carrying a firearm and you just might have to shoot someone. Have you ever considered the psychological, legal and financial ramifications of pulling that trigger in the name of "self-defense"? Are you prepared to potentially lose your livelihood, your daughter and your freedom because of that decision? If we start probing, the questions become endless.

Not sure what the requirements are in CA for a CCW. Again, I can only speak to Louisiana. I had to sign two HIPAAs for Louisiana to request my medical records to approve me for a concealed permit. I signed those with zero hesitation. I’m all for it. If required to see a psychologist, sure. I think that’s great, but Louisiana didn’t require that for me.

As far as the ramifications go, I think about it daily. Car jackings in NOLA are insane. Recently here a woman’s arm was severed in a car jacking attempt and she died on scene. Louisiana has a “shoot the car jacker” law, which protects the victim (as it should). Louisiana is a stand your ground state with no duty to retreat. I have USCCA insurance. I hope to never have to pull the trigger, but in the event I fear for my life, or my child’s, etc., I will pull it.

Again, I don’t have all the answers. I just hope anyone who is able to purchase a gun is physically and mentally capable of being a responsible gun owner. Easier said than done, I just hope some changes are made

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by Sara

Not sure what the requirements are in CA for a CCW. Again, I can only speak to Louisiana. I had to sign two HIPAAs for Louisiana to request my medical records to approve me for a concealed permit. I signed those with zero hesitation. I'm all for it. If required to see a psychologist, sure. I think that's great, but Louisiana didn't require that for me. As far as the ramifications go, I think about it daily. Car jackings in NOLA are insane. Recently here a woman's arm was severed in a car jacking attempt and she died on scene. Louisiana has a "shoot the car jacker" law, which protects the victim (as it should). Louisiana is a stand your ground state with no duty to retreat. I have USCCA insurance. I hope to never have to pull the trigger, but in the event I fear for my life, or my child's, etc., I will pull it.

Not everybody is comfortable with that even if there's no mental disorder to conceal. Absorbing the financial impact of regular psych visits just to be able to defend yourself isn't ideal either. Subjecting the law abiding public to these suggested restrictions does nothing to address the real and pervasive issue (…which isn't firearms in the possession of law abiding citizens). Criminals and people intent on causing mass harm do not play by any of these rules. Like someone mentioned, some people deteriorate mentally over time. A mentally sound Sara today may not be the case two years from now. Are you going to readily relinquish your firearms should you decline? I doubt it, but I fully expect you to say that you would because…..appearances.

[Sara]

Originally Posted by Sedan_Clan

Not everybody is comfortable with that even if there's no mental disorder to conceal. Like someone mentioned, some people deteriorate mentally over time. A mentally sound Sara today may not be the case two years from now. Are you going to readily relinquish your firearms should you decline? I doubt it, but I fully expect you to say that you would because…..appearances.

You know, I actually have thought about that. And the answer is yes, I would. Same as I would with my driver’s license. Should I reach a point where I can no longer operate a vehicle safely, should I be on the road behind the wheel? No.

Speaking of, I wish the DMV had annual testing renewals or something. I swear the people down here make me wonder who passed them on their driving tests I was actually rear ended in April this year. An suv slammed into me while I was at a stop on the expressway. Driver “dozed off” as they stated to the police. It was 08:30. To me, if you’ve got a medical condition where you “doze off” while driving, you shouldn’t be permitted to be behind the wheel!! I was injured and my vehicle was moderately damaged. Their vehicle was totaled. Thankfully, I have youth on my side and good health and I’m fine now, but imagine if they had hit someone else instead of me, and killed that person… guns aren’t for everyone and neither is driving. Not everyone’s going to agree, but that’s just what I think.

[ezaircon4jc]

So... You guys that want restrictions on the 2nd Amendment, do you also want them on the 5th?, 4th?, 3rd, 10th or any of the other BILL OF RIGHTS?

[jamesinaz]

Until and unless congress passes a constitutional amendment deleting the 2nd A I am not in favor of any more restrictions on ownership or purchasing of firearms. For me the constitution IS a living document but only via the specific methods defined within it and the "death of a 1000 cuts" that gun banners are implementing makes all our rights less secure. And to date none of the suggestions ever passed in any state have done anything to make us safer.

Having said that, I'd be OK with secure background checks including linking mental health databases with the current federal background check. And we could stand to improve our nations mental health services.

I can't claim I know answers to all of societies issues but it sure seems to me that school shootings would be better resolved with seriously secure campus settings and an armed response within each school.

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by ezaircon4jc

So... You guys that want restrictions on the 2nd Amendment, do you also want them on the 5th?, 4th?, 3rd, 10th or any of the other BILL OF RIGHTS?

They probably do. It's the same people who are okay with freedom of speech as long as it coincides with their own belief system(s). Anything less and it's deemed hate speech, racist, misinformation, xenophobic, etc. They shift the pendulum to fit their own criteria. Rights are equal across the board.

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by jamesinaz

Until and unless congress passes a constitutional amendment deleting the 2nd A I am not in favor of any more restrictions on ownership or purchasing of firearms. For me the constitution IS a living document but only via the specific methods defined within it and the "death of a 1000 cuts" that gun banners are implementing makes all our rights less secure. And to date none of the suggestions ever passed in any state have done anything to make us safer.

Having said that, I'd be OK with secure background checks including linking mental health databases with the current federal background check. And we could stand to improve our nations mental health services.

I can't claim I know answers to all of societies issues but it sure seems to me that school shootings would be better resolved with seriously secure campus settings and an armed response within each school.

Well stated and I agree with majority of what you have said.

The issue with mental health services is this: the government does not care. It's all empty rhetoric. Very little is done to deal with the issue. Much like the approach to curtailing crime, homelessness, etc., most of the implementation(s) is/are the equivalent using a band-aid for a cut that requires sutures.

[Shiza]

Anyone else on here reload? I have a few pounds of a few different powders for various cartridges. I know the powder needs to be kept in a cool/dry place as moisture can have adverse effects on it, but I've always felt a bit weird or uneasy keeping it in the house, more specifically the safe. Especially with a newborn about a month away. Anyone else experience this anxiety? Or am I overthinking it?

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by Shiza

Anyone else on here reload? I have a few pounds of a few different powders for various cartridges. I know the powder needs to be kept in a cool/dry place as moisture can have adverse effects on it, but I've always felt a bit weird or uneasy keeping it in the house, more specifically the safe. Especially with a newborn about a month away. Anyone else experience this anxiety? Or am I overthinking it?

I've considered getting into it. I just don't shoot enough to make it financially worthwhile at this time, but I do plan to learn. Self-sufficiency is the name of the game.

[Shiza]

Originally Posted by Sedan_Clan

I've considered getting into it. I just don't shoot enough to make it financially worthwhile at this time, but I do plan to learn. Self-sufficiency is the name of the game.

I enjoy it when I have the time. I started in 2020 when I purchased a rifle chambered in 6.5 creedmoor then realized I couldn't find ammo anywhere. I now do 9mm, 30-06, 6.5, and 45acp. Some cartridges are worthwhile while others won't yield much return. I would say it is a skill worth having though.

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by Shiza

I enjoy it when I have the time. I started in 2020 when I purchased a rifle chambered in 6.5 creedmoor then realized I couldn't find ammo anywhere. I now do 9mm, 30-06, 6.5, and 45acp. Some cartridges are worthwhile while others won't yield much return. I would say it is a skill worth having though.

I agree. I have a couple of buddies who reload, mill lowers, etc. and it's an awesome set of skills to have.

[Shiza]

Originally Posted by Sedan_Clan

I agree. I have a couple of buddies who reload, mill lowers, etc. and it's an awesome set of skills to have.

80's we're recently banned here in MD but you just reminded me to definitely not finish milling mine out this weekend

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by Shiza

80's we're recently banned here in MD but you just reminded me to definitely not finish milling mine out this weekend

Haha! When the SHTF, none of the laws will matter. Stay prepared and ready!!!!

[vreihen16]

Originally Posted by Shiza

Anyone else on here reload? I have a few pounds of a few different powders for various cartridges. I know the powder needs to be kept in a cool/dry place as moisture can have adverse effects on it, but I've always felt a bit weird or uneasy keeping it in the house, more specifically the safe. Especially with a newborn about a month away. Anyone else experience this anxiety? Or am I overthinking it?

I know of a small electronics/tech company that has a reloading room with all of the tools and stuff, as an employee benefits perk for recruiting. They also have a company group membership at a local range.....

[paquet]

Originally Posted by Sedan_Clan

Ask the citizens of Australia or Cuba that question. I'm sure you'd get a mouthful. The second amendment was written for BOTH foreign AND domestic invaders (…which could be an assault from your own government). There's a reason the U.S. is the last true free society, and that's because, as a people, we have a means of defense.

You are naive as hell if you think a baseball bat is going to do anything for you. It's apparent you are anti-2A, but this country was founded using firearms. It's engrained in the culture of this country.

….and stop blaming guns and gun owners for that tragedy in Texas. Disgusting!

Add Canada to the list too.
The government (never missing a chance to exploit a tragedy) is looking at additional laws in Canada while completely ignoring the real issues and players

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by packet

Add Canada to the list too.
The government (never missing a chance to exploit a tragedy) is looking at additional laws in Canada while completely ignoring the real issues and players

I was going to add you guys to the list. There's a lot of tension up there and the Patriots down here feel for you guys.