[swartzentruber]

Like Rekrul, can we vote none of the above? You can get a brand new R8 for not that much more with full warranty. I think you'd be crazy to spend that kind of money on a 4 year old R8. Also, if I want "practicality", I'd be looking at a lightly used Turbo over a lightly used R8. As for the Ferrari, not a huge fan of either the 360 or the 430, but really like the 458 redesign. I guess I'd probably pick the 430. Also, that a damn old car if that's your primary car, and not a weekend/show/garage car.

Edit: I just priced out a brand new R8 tiptronic for $130k. If you can afford a 4 year old used car for $95k, you should be able to afford $130k for a brand new one, but that's just me.